M. Natali, for BDGest, says that the manga "shows the evolution of the ideals of young girls of today". M. Natali felt the closeup pictures were effective in showing attitudes and emotions, but regretted the at times over-long dialogues. The reviewer for Manga News said described the story as "sweet and poignant", but not weepy, as there was humour.
Deb Aoki, writing for About.com, says that "we see the life-changing decisions and the complexities of love and family relationships in modern Japan, as only Fumi Yoshinaga (creator of Ooku and Antique Bakery) can tell them". Shaenon Garrity, writing for The Comics Journal, describes the manga as "three generations of mothers and daughters screwing each other up in new and creative ways", and notes that "what goes on between the ears is much wilder, woolier, and scarier than what goes on between the legs". Marissa Sammy, writing for Sequential Tart, felt the manga was "a hard book to get through, in a way", describing the manga as being in a "bruised space, where there are no quick and easy answers but instead the love and frustration and responsibility of real life and real relationships". Holly Ellingwood sums up the manga by saying that it's "five moving tales of the relationships of mothers, daughters, and the love that exists between them." Leroy Douresseaux felt that it sometimes felt like a soap opera but that Yoshinaga's insight made the manga "worth reading". Johanna Draper Carlson felt it was "unusual to see family and relationship conflicts of this type in comics, especially portrayed in such a raw fashion with such insight". Michelle Smith describes Yoshinaga's story as "thoughtful, integrated", and noted Yoshinaga's use of closeups to convey emotion.
- ↑ Script error
- ↑ http://www.viz.com/products/products.php?product_id=8770
- ↑ http://www.sakka.info/Albums_Detail.cfm?ID=32471
- ↑ http://www.spp.com.tw/spp2006/all/asp/search/bookfile.asp?bc=21210236&vch=comic/
- ↑ Jury Recommended Works
- ↑ http://www.bdgest.com/chronique-1786-BD-All-My-Darling-Daughters.html
- ↑ http://www.manga-news.com/index.php/manga/All-my-darling-daughters#review
- ↑ About.com 2010 Preview: 25 Hot New Manga
- ↑ http://www.tcj.com/manga/sex-and-eclairs-and-fumi-yoshinaga
- ↑ ST
- ↑ AA
- ↑ CBB
- ↑ CWR
- ↑ PCS